119-121 Lexington Avenue

*Dear Future Homeowner,*

We’ve loved our six years in this house, and writing this letter brings so many bittersweet feelings - so please know it comes from the heart. Hilton is a neighborhood filled with friendly, welcoming neighbors who always look out for one another. Whether it’s picking up mail, feeding pets, or simply sharing a chat over the fence, you’ll never feel alone here. There’s a true sense of community and connection, and we mean it. Maplewood - especially the Hilton neighborhood - is an incredibly special, one-of-a-kind place.
Our home is located right in the heart of Hilton. Every year, the much-loved Porchfest formally kicks off right in front of our house. In fact, the previous owner started Porchfest, and it continues to be one of the highlights of the neighborhood - a celebration of camaraderie we’ve been proud to be part of.
One of the things we’ve loved most about living here is being able to walk everywhere - and we do it daily! From coffee to wine, to the many new businesses that keep popping up, everything you need is just a short stroll away. If you haven’t heard of the town jitney, it’s just one block from our home and makes commuting a breeze, shuttling you straight to the train station each morning. It’s such a convenient bonus.
Over the years, we’ve poured love into updating and renovating nearly every part of this house. From major projects like redesigning the staircase and opening up the living and dining rooms, to adding new siding, gardens, flooring, and lighting - each change has been made with thoughtful purpose. Our favorite renovation is the spa-like bathroom and walk-in closet in the primary suite. It can’t be beat, and we’ll surely miss it! Every decision we made was about optimizing the home for convenient daily living and joyful entertaining, and we hope the next family enjoys it as much as we have.
The backyard has been one of our favorite spaces. We’ve hosted birthday parties with 50+ guests, family BBQs, and countless evenings of dining on the patio. We’ve loved watching our son and his friends bounce, splash, and play, while our dogs explored safely in the fully fenced yard. Springtime blooms with peonies, roses, and colorful flowers, while summer brings fresh tomatoes and zucchini from our vegetable garden - a joy we’ve shared with friends and neighbors.
There’s so much more we could say about how much joy this home has given us. When we moved here from California six years ago, we didn’t know much about Maplewood beyond its charming downtown and train line. But since then, this house has been our sanctuary, our party venue, the place where we welcomed our first child, shared life with our beloved pets, and celebrated new jobs, friendships, and milestones. It’s been the center of our family story.
We hope you fall in love with this home - and with Maplewood - just as we did. We’ve put so much love and care into every inch, and we truly want to pass along all the joy, warmth, and memories we’ve been blessed to experience here.
Sincerely,
The Current Homeowners of 119-121 Lexington Ave

Reel Estate

A walkthrough of 119-121 Lexington Avenue, Maplewood NJ

Cape Cod charm meets cottage cozy with a hint of bungalow magic in this fully reimagined, picture-perfect home! Every space has been thoughtfully reimagined to blend style, comfort, and character in one unforgettable home. Nestled in a beloved, tight-knit neighborhood bursting with creative energy, this home blends style and soul in all the right ways. Step into the enclosed front porch dripping with cozy character and into the welcoming foyer and beautifully rebuilt staircase. Inside, the charm continues into a sunny front room perfect for a music nook, home office, or dreamy reading space. The spacious dining room flows seamlessly into the open-concept kitchen with a large island and family room made for entertaining. Need flex space? The first-floor bedroom doubles as an office or playroom, with a full bathroom nearby for convenience. Downstairs, the finished basement offers the ultimate hangout zone for movie nights, guests, or play - plus endless storage. Upstairs is the primary suite of your dreams! A designer bathroom with marble details, a custom shower, built-ins, along with a walk-in closet, and thoughtful details throughout. A third bedroom adds even more charm and versatility. Out back, enjoy a large fully fenced yard, patio for lounging, and a two-car garage. High-efficiency central air adds to the modern updates. Just blocks to two parks, Hilton Library, restaurants & shops, and an easy commute to NYC. Low taxes! This is the GEM you've been waiting for!