5 Fairview Terrace
Dear Future Homeowner,
Welcome to your new home. Our journey here began when a career move brought us from North Carolina to the New York area. We arrived searching for the same sense of peace and sanctuary we had left behind, and the moment we first stepped into this house, we knew we had found it.
There is a rare, beautiful balance to living here. In the mornings, you can listen to the birds and watch wildlife wander through the backyard, yet you remain just five minutes from the train into the city. It is an incredible neighborhood that offers quietude without sacrificing access to the world.
We have spent years lovingly tending to the grounds, adding many plantings from our favorite local nursery and special transplants from a parent’s garden. It is our hope that you find joy in watching these bloom in succession throughout the seasons.
Life in this community is uniquely vibrant. We have cherished our weekend morning walks to Able Baker for coffee and gluten-free scones, evening cocktails at Lorena’s, dinners at Luna Stella and the many festivals that bring South Orange and Maplewood to life. Meeting up with neighbors in town for drinks or dinner made us feel like we were really part of the community.
This house has been the backdrop for our most significant milestones, including graduating two children who grew up playing in this backyard. As we pass the keys to you, we hope you enjoy the updates and improvements we’ve made over the years. They were completed with a deep respect for the home’s history, intended to ensure this structure stands strong and welcoming for another hundred years.
May you find as much peace and happiness within these walls as we have.
Warmly,
The Johnstone-Yurko Family
Reel Estate
Video Walkthrough of 5 Fairview Terrace, Maplewood NJ
ARRIVING HOME
Visit this home in person for a free copy of the 5 Fairview Terrace edition of our magazine Arriving Home
With unmatched storybook curb appeal, it's the warmth, character, and feeling of home that make this 4 bedroom, 3 bath Maplewood gem truly unforgettable! Set on a picturesque, tree-lined street with deep lots and layered landscaping, this neighborhood is serene yet only .7 mi to town. Stepping in, there's a welcoming energy that instantly makes it feel like home. The sunken living room is dramatic and inviting, centered around an incredible stone fireplace and framed by windows that fill the space with light. Throughout the home, original details have been preserved & celebrated, including leaded glass casement windows - casting the most beautiful light and a sense of history and charm. A den provides the perfect secondary living space, while a 1st floor bedroom sits beside a truly special full bath - ideal for guests or a work-from-home retreat. The custom kitchen with high-end, design-forward finishes feels elevated, and perfectly in tune with the home’s architecture. The bedrooms are incredibly generous, offering room to grow, and the primary bath delivers a spa-like experience. The finished basement is a perfect place to hang or play. Outside, the landscaping and backyard create a private, idyllic escape perfect for morning coffee & dinners. Just a short stroll to Maplewood Village, with its beloved shops, restaurants, & NYC train, this location offers the best of all worlds! A home filled with soul, beauty, and tranquility - a truly special place to call home!
Floorplan
Property Information
5 Fairview Terrace,
Maplewood NJ 07040
Listing Price: $1,249,000
4 Bedrooms
3 Full Bathrooms
2 Built in Garage
Lot Size: 0.24 acres
Property Style: Tudor
Ideal Closing: 7/31/2026
Estimated Taxes: $28,958* / 2025*
*Inquire with tax assessor for 2026 numbers
FAVORITE FEATURES
Instantly welcoming neighborhood with strong sense of community
Perfect balance of connection and privacy—tucked into a wooded, serene setting
Highly walkable location near train, restaurants, and shops
Easy NYC access for dining, culture, and entertainment
Ideal lifestyle: morning coffee at Able Baker + nearby South Mountain hikes
Convenient to everyday essentials and local favorites
A wonderful place to raise a family
A home filled with positive energy and a true sense of belonging
UPDATES
2026
Exterior house cleaning (April 2026)
Moss treatment on roof
Annual gutter cleaning
2025–2022
Smart home upgrades: Nest system, Philips lighting, app-controlled dimmers
2023
Patio installation
Timer-controlled lighted stairway
Grill gas hookup
Backyard leveling and retaining wall
2022
Downspouts replaced
Continued flower bed enhancements (2019–2022)
2020
Driveway repaved and expanded/lengthened
Chimney external bricks repointed by Pigna Masons
2019
French drain installed
Chimney flue relined
Flower beds created (begun)
2018 (Prior Owner)
Front walk and railing
2016 (Prior Owner)
Roof
APPROXIMATE MONTHLY UTILITIES
Electric/Gas(PSEG):
$450
American Water:
$41.25/monthly average
Waste Management:
$120
Cleaner:
$150/service
Downloadable Documents
Map
Map to Maplewood Train Station
Map to Jitney
Contact Information
Denise Payne
Realtor® / Sales Associate
Direct: (973) 544-8484
Office: (973) 376-0033
Keller Williams Premier Properties
518 Millburn Avenue, Short Hills NJ