93 Plymouth Avenue
Dear Future Homeowner,
We fell in love with 93 Plymouth Avenue the minute we laid eyes on it. The Cherry Kwanzan Tree was in full bloom and the neighborhood kids were playing in the tree lined street. We stepped inside and immediately felt embraced by the warmth and positive energy of the home. Like many other families in Maplewood, we were transplants from the city looking for more space and a community to raise our 5 children ranging in age from 10 years to 6 months. Now 18 years have passed and as I sit here and reflect on what this home has meant to us, I am overwhelmed by all the memories. This home has been the gathering point for our family, friends, our children’s friends, and neighbors; somehow always expanding to allow room for everyone.
As you step inside, you will find a home that is both warm and functional. It offers 4 full floors of living space with an easy flow from room to room; allowing for large gatherings or different groups of kids’ friends to break off in separate spaces – be it the basement for movie nights or the garage for band practice. The primary suite on the top floor is a true sanctuary and 18 years later I still feel as if I’m stepping into another world at the end of the day - one filled with peace and tranquility. Another favorite part of the home is the amazing outdoor deck which creates additional living and dining space from April – October. Hanging on the deck at the end of the day surrounded by beautiful old trees has been a daily blessing.
Our street has a tremendous sense of community and has felt more like an extended family. When we moved here we were told this was the best block in Maplewood and I can now say that it is 100% true. At the end of the street is Maplecrest Park with a playground, skate park, and library. We are a hop, skip, and a jump away from 3 elementary schools (Tuscan, Clinton, and Seth Boyden), Maplewood Middle School, and Columbia High school as well as the Maplewood Community Pool. Town is a mere 20 min walk away with an amazing selection of restaurants as is Artie’s and Perla in the Hilton neighborhood. This is truly the absolute best location in all of Maplewood.
I hope you will feel the love that this home has held, and that you will get an opportunity to create your own amazing memories.
With Love,
Ane + Family
“REEL” ESTATE
A walkthrough of 93 Plymouth Avenue, Maplewood NJ
At last, the Maplewood gem you’ve been dreaming of! This timeless center hall Colonial offers four full floors of updated living space, all just a short stroll from vibrant downtown Maplewood and direct trains to NYC. Also just one block to Maplecrest Park with its playground, baseball fields, and library. With the curb appeal you've been dreaming of, step inside and be greeted by a sun-drenched living room, where a classic brick fireplace serves as a warm and welcoming centerpiece. Wrapped in windows, the adjacent sunroom offers serene backyard views - perfect for a cozy lounge, home office, or playroom. Entertain in style with the seamless flow from the gracious dining room into a charming kitchen, where vintage character meets modern flair - complete with stainless steel appliances and stone countertops. Upstairs on the 2nd fl, discover four bright and spacious bedrooms and a full bath with double sinks. The third-floor ensuite is a peaceful sanctuary with a private full bath - a potential luxe primary retreat. The fully finished basement adds even more flexible living space, including a full bath, potential office nook, and ample storage. Step outside onto the expansive deck - perfect for al fresco gatherings, morning coffee, and summer soirées. The backyard is a deep, lush retreat ready for endless play and relaxation. The garage has been transformed into a hangout space with generous storage. Located in a beloved Maplewood neighborhood, this home truly has it all!
Floorplan
entry
LIVING ROOM
DINING ROOM
KITCHEN
SUNROOM
PRIMARY SUITE
SECOND Floor
BEDROOMS & SPACES
lower level
garage hangout
OUTDOOR SPACE
FAVORITE FEATURES
Thoughtfully designed layout with 4 full floors of living space
– perfect for gathering together or allowing adults, teens, and kids to spread out
Expansive deck ideal for BBQs, lounging, and entertaining
Exceptionally solid construction – no basement water issues in 20 years
Warm, welcoming energy – a home filled with love and good memories
Gorgeous front tree adds charm and curb appeal
Located on one of Maplewood’s most beloved blocks with a strong community vibe
Just down the street from a local park
Walkable to 3 elementary schools: Tuscan, Hilton, and Seth Boyden
Also walkable to Maplewood Middle School and Columbia High School
Convenient access to town center, community pool, and Hilton Library
Jitney stop around the corner for easy NYC commuting
Flooded with natural light – bright and sunny throughout
Detached garage repurposed as a casual hangout space
High-quality materials and solid construction create a comfortable internal climate year-round
UPDATES
2024
Newly painted exterior
2023
New central air conditioning
New water heater
2021
Partial bathroom renovation on second floor
2012
New primary bath on 3rd floor, full renovation
2010
New deck
Marble countertops in kitchen
Driveway repaved
APPROXIMATE UTILITIES
Water:
$60/month
PSE&G:
$300/month
Downloadable Documents
Map
Map to Maplewood Station
Map to Jitney
Property Information
93 Plymouth Avenue
Maplewood NJ 07040
Listing Price: $895,000
5 Bedrooms
3 Full Bathrooms
Lot Size: 0.17 acres
Property Style: Colonial
Ideal Closing Date: July 28, 2025
*2024 Est Taxes: $20,655*
*Inquire with tax assessor for 2025 numbers
Contact Information
Denise Payne
Realtor / Sales Associate
Direct: (973) 544-8484
Office: (973) 376-0033
Keller Williams Premier Properties
518 Millburn Avenue, Short Hills NJ
