21 Carter Road
21 Carter Road, West Orange NJ 07052
Listing Price: $749,000
4 Bedrooms
2 Full Bathrooms
1 Half Bathroom
1 Attached Car Garage
Lot Size: 0.19 acres
Property Style: Cape Cod
Ideal Closing Date: Fast Closing Preferred
Estimated Taxes: $19,965* / 2025*
*Inquire with tax assessor for 2026 numbers
Dear Future Homeowner,
What we have loved most about 21 Carter Road is how easy it has been to make a life here. This is where we started our family, and both the house and the neighborhood have been such a special part of that experience.
The layout has worked so well for us. The two large bedrooms upstairs and full bath gave us plenty of space as our family grew, and there is so much storage and closet space throughout the house—something you appreciate even more once you have a child! The two large bedrooms on the main floor have also been wonderful for hosting our parents and friends when they come into town. Everyone has space to feel comfortable, and we have loved being able to have the people closest to us stay with us.
In the basement we created a home gym and a movie area for the whole family. It has been wonderful having that extra space to work out, relax, or spend a night watching movies together.
One of our favorite things about the neighborhood is seeing everyone out in the early evenings. Families take walks with their kids, neighbors stop to catch up, and you often end up talking in the street longer than you planned. Between the annual block parties and those everyday conversations, you get to know the people around you. That sense of community has meant a lot to us.
We also love how convenient the location is. You can walk in the morning to the West Orange jitney for a ride to the South Orange train station to commute to Penn Station, and seeing parents walking their children to school is part of the daily rhythm of the Carter Road neighborhood.
With a young daughter, being close to Turtle Back Zoo has been a huge plus. It makes it easy to plan something fun without making it an all-day outing. The South Mountain Recreation Complex, the waterfront walking path, playground and the nearby reservation give you so many options to get outside. We have really appreciated having those places close to home, along with the restaurants and shops in West Orange, South Orange, and Maplewood.
For us, this home has been a comfortable place to settle into family life, with room to grow and plenty to enjoy nearby. We have put care into making it work for our family, and it is hard to leave the place where so many of our memories began.
We hope you love living here as much as we have and that the house becomes the setting for many happy memories of your own.
Warmly,
The Current Homeowners of 21 Carter Road
REEL ESTATE
Video Walkthrough of 21 Carter Road, West Orange NJ
ARRIVING HOME
Visit this home in person for a free copy of the 21 Carter Road edition of our magazine Arriving Home
Prepare to be surprised by this fully updated and incredibly special home on a picture perfect cul de sac in a beloved West Orange neighborhood! Brimming with storybook charm yet wonderfully open and spacious, this sun-filled 4 BR, 2.1 BA home offers the best of both worlds. Hardwood floors, incredible character and beautiful natural light create warmth throughout. The inviting living room flows into an open updated eat-in kitchen with breakfast bar, stainless appliances and direct access to the backyard. Just beyond, a charming sunroom wrapped in windows is the dreamiest spot for an office, playroom or peaceful retreat. Two generous bedrooms and a full bath on EACH of the first and second floors offer exceptional flexibility. Downstairs, the finished basement is a cozy haven for movie nights, family fun and a home gym, with a powder room and HUGE unfinished storage area. Outside, enjoy lovely tiered gardens, a patio and refreshed landscaping. Thoughtful improvements include updated HVAC components, French drain, new dishwasher and more. And the neighborhood is just as special! Think friendly neighbors, bike riding, annual block parties and a true sense of community. Near schools, parks, Turtle Back Zoo, South Mountain Reservation, shopping and restaurants, with convenient Jitney access to South Orange's NYC trains. A home filled with heart, character and unexpected space, ready for its next chapter!
FLOORPLAN
FAVORITE FEATURES
Wonderful Sense of Community: An incredible neighborhood where neighbors know one another, stop to chat in the street, and genuinely look out for each other. There's a warmth and friendliness that makes this neighborhood feel like home.
Welcoming, Close-Knit Neighborhood: On any given evening, you'll see families taking walks with their children, kids riding their bikes, and neighbors catching up along the way. A welcoming, close-knit neighborhood that offers a wonderful place to start and grow a family.
Walkable School & Easy NYC Commute: The convenience of being able to walk to the neighborhood school and having easy access to the West Orange Jitney, which provides transportation to the South Orange train station. A wonderful balance of peaceful suburban living and convenient access to New York City.
Neighborhood Block Parties: Annual neighborhood block parties are a much-loved tradition! Between these gatherings and the spontaneous conversations that happen in the street, there's a genuine sense of connection and friendship that makes living here so special.
Generous Bedrooms & Abundant Storage: The two generously sized bedrooms on the second floor provide wonderful space and flexibility as needs change. An abundance of closets and storage throughout the home adds everyday practicality, while the spacious guest bedroom on the main level is perfect for welcoming parents, extended family and visiting guests.
Finished Basement for Fitness & Entertainment: Thoughtfully finished to create a dedicated home gym and family movie area. Whether fitting in a workout, enjoying a cozy movie night or simply spending quality time together, this additional living space is a wonderful feature of the
Comfortable & Flexible Layout: The home's layout makes everyday living and entertaining feel effortless. Between the comfortable living areas, generous bedrooms and plentiful storage, the house easily accommodates family life, visiting guests and changing needs.
Beautiful Tiered Backyard: A special outdoor space offering everything from peaceful mornings to family barbecues, entertaining friends and spending time together.
Incredible Location & Nearby Amenities: The best of both worlds, with Turtle Back Zoo, South Mountain Reservation and numerous parks and recreational opportunities nearby. Everyday conveniences are equally accessible, including Essex Green Shopping Center, Target, Whole Foods and a variety of restaurants and shops. The planned addition of Trader Joe's to the area offers another exciting convenience.
A Home Filled with Meaningful Memories: A home that has been the backdrop to so many special experiences, from family celebrations and backyard barbecues to cozy movie nights and the simple moments of everyday life. Beyond the house itself, the wonderful neighbors, friendships and true sense of belonging make this a truly special place to call home, with so many opportunities for its next owners to create beautiful memories of their own.
UPDATES
2026:
New HVAC Condenser and Evaporator Coil
Half Bathroom Renovation
2025:
Interior design touches added to basement
New Samsung Bespoke Dishwasher
French Drain Installed
Front Landscaping
APPROXIMATE MONTHLY UTILITIES
Electric and Gas:
$300
Water:
$67
Downloadable Documents
MAP
CONTACT INFORMATION
Denise Payne
Realtor® / Sales Associate
Direct: (973) 544-8484
Office: (973) 376-0033
Keller Williams Premier Properties
518 Millburn Avenue, Short Hills NJ