447-449 Elmwood Avenue
Dear Future Homeowner,
If you’re reading this, you’re considering a home that meant so much to us—and we’re truly honored to share a bit of what made it special.
The backyard quickly became the heart of our life here. Fully enclosed and tucked away, it feels like a private oasis right in the middle of town. It’s where mornings began with coffee, weekends stretched into long dinners, and evenings wound down with a quiet glass of wine after the kids were asleep. We spent more time out there than anywhere else, and it has a way of inviting you to slow down and simply be.
Inside, the home has a warmth and character that’s hard to replicate. It’s not cookie-cutter—and that’s exactly what drew us in from the start. The original details give it soul, and as we made updates over time, we tried to honor that—modernizing where it mattered, while preserving what made it feel so special.
And then there’s Maplewood. Living here becomes part of your daily rhythm. Walking into the Village for coffee or dinner, running errands on foot, and seeing familiar faces along the way—it all adds up to something meaningful. The community is real and welcoming, with a beautiful mix of people and stories. You feel it everywhere—from school pickups (although the bus has picked up our kids right out front), to the farmers market to neighborhood gatherings. It’s a place where connection comes naturally.
Our time here, while it feels like it went by quickly, was filled with moments we’ll always carry with us. We cared deeply for this home and hope that as you walk through it, you can begin to imagine your own memories taking shape here.
With warmth,
The Current Owners
Reel Estate
Video Walkthrough of 447-449 Elmwood Avenue, Maplewood NJ
ARRIVING HOME
Visit this home in person for a free copy of the 447-449 Elmwood Avenue edition of our magazine Arriving Home
This captivating and beautifully updated Maplewood Victorian offers the perfect blend of original character and modern living, ideally designed for both indoor/outdoor entertaining, featuring a welcoming, freshly painted wraparound porch with ample space for lounging and dining—perfect for enjoying summer days and evenings.
Inside this 4 bedroom home, timeless details are complemented by thoughtful updates such as a renovated kitchen with marble countertops, Viking range, all new hardwood floors throughout and two-zone central air. The sun-filled eat-in kitchen flows easily for everyday living and overlooks the expansive backyard. The inviting front living room opens to the porch via French doors, while th dining room turned family room off the kitchen offers flexible space. A mudroom and full bath complete the first floor.
Upstairs are three bedrooms including a spacious primary with large walk-in closet, plus a full hall bath. The third floor offers additional space for primary suite, office, perhaps guests, or recreation. The finished basement provides room for playspace, media room, and laundry.
The backyard space is a true highlight - double the typical width, enjoy the European style stone patio area, dining space, all fenced and expansive, with room for entertaining, gardening, and play, along with a two-car garage with loft storage. This is a rare opportunity to enjoy a character-filled home with modern updates in a prime Maplewood location.
Floorplan
Property Archive
Property Information
447-449 Elmwood Avenue, Maplewood NJ 07040
Listing Price: $989,000
4 Bedrooms
2 Full Bathrooms
2 Detached Garage
Lot Size: 0.16 acres
Property Style: Colonial/Victorian
Ideal Closing: 8/1/2026
Estimated Taxes: $18,984*/ 2025*
*Inquire with tax assessor for 2026 numbers
FAVORITE FEATURES
The backyard is a true urban oasis. Fully enclosed and tucked away, the outdoor space feels like a secret garden—completely private, yet right in the heart of town. It’s the kind of yard you actually live in: morning coffee, weekend dinners with friends, and quiet evenings to unwind.
A home with real character. This isn’t a cookie-cutter house. It has soul—original details, warmth, and charm that can’t be replicated, paired with thoughtful updates for modern living.
Updated, but not over-renovated. The kitchen, baths, and key systems have been brought into the present, while the bones, woodwork, and architectural details have been preserved. A balance today’s buyers are truly looking for.
A genuinely diverse community. The neighborhood offers a meaningful mix of people, backgrounds, and perspectives, creating a welcoming and vibrant environment.
Maplewood Village is a “5-minute everything.” The walk into town becomes part of daily life—coffee, dining, and errands all easily accessible. Recognized as one of Matador Network’s “25 Coolest Towns in America,” and it shows.
The commute is effortless. Maplewood Station offers Midtown Direct service to NYC Penn in under 35 minutes, with Newark Airport just 15 minutes away.
A town that shows up for itself. Memorial Park, the town pool, Maplewoodstock, and year-round festivals create a rhythm and energy that make the community feel alive.
A neighborhood that truly connects. Neighbors who wave, look out for each other, and create that small-town feel—just 20 miles from Manhattan.
UPDATES
2026
• Interior repaint
• Kitchen updates including replacement cabinet doors and $1,000+ in new hardware
2025
• Stairs refinished
2022
• New flooring installed throughout
• Full interior repaint
Recent Outdoor Improvements
• Backyard renovation including custom planters, gravel patio, new lawn, and stone pathway
APPROXIMATE MONTHLY UTILITIES
Electric/Gas(PSEG):
$427
Water:
$50
Internet(wifi only):
$79
Downloadable Documents
Map
Map to Maplewood Train Station
Map to Jitney
Contact Information
VANESSA POLLOCK
Founder
Realtor® / Sales Associate
Direct: (973) 544-8484
Office: (973) 376-0033
Keller Williams Premier Properties
518 Millburn Avenue, Short Hills NJ