9 Amherst Court
Dear Future Homeowner,
Time heals. This house taught us that. On one of our first nights here, we went exploring in the crawl spaces. We found bottles dating back to 1858. One was corked with a newspaper article from 1941.
Underneath the bottles was a cornerstone in the foundation! It said — says — 1927. And stretching across that same basement was — is — a wooden beam as long as a tree is tall. My mom said, “they don’t even have lumber like this anymore.”
Being surrounded by that history helped us see that we were part of a continuum. The house represented a lineage, protecting family after family under its roof through each season. And it protected us through the seasons, too.
In the fall, we sat around the fire pit with neighbors and roasted chestnuts and marshmallows.
In the winter, we warmed up in the kitchen at the breakfast bar, using it as an evening spot for hot tea and decompressing.
In the spring, we cherished our first outdoor dinners of the year and watched the bunnies emerge.
And in the summer, we walked to the pool in the day, and held dance parties among the fireflies and under the dogwood at night.
Maplecrest Park next door is a beacon through all the seasons, with its cherry blossoms in the spring and vibrant colors in the fall. Hemlock Falls, ten minutes away, is a veritable snow globe in the winter—and an oasis in the summer.
Mamas II: best Mac and cheese I’ve ever had. Porta Rossa: Pasta en Brodo during winter is a salve. Views from the library; ice cream in the round. Diwali and Habibi fests. Christmas and Hanukkah concerts. Tennis tournaments and volunteering and our neighbor’s bookclub.
We were nurtured by the community here. We made real friends—people we’ll keep forever, through seasons and time.
The only constant in life is change. But this house gave us a beautiful place to grow. And like all the families under its roof, and within its continuum, I believe yours will too.
Warmly,
The Current Homeowners of 9 Amherst Court
Reel Estate
Video Walkthrough of 9 Amherst Court, Maplewood NJ
ARRIVING HOME
Visit this home in person for a free copy of the 9 Amherst Court edition of our magazine Arriving Home
Thoughtfully updated and elegantly maintained, this pristine Colonial offers a rare blend of character, craftsmanship, and modern comfort - steps from Maplecrest Park and an easy train ride to NYC. The heart of 9 Amherst Court is the oversized, custom-renovated kitchen-intuitively structured with built-in stainless steel appliances, generous workspace, and seamless connection to the indoor dining and living spaces. The kitchen's counterpart is a natural extension of the home: a state-of-the-art stone patio and outdoor dining area. The sitting wall, built from locally sourced New Jersey stone and bluestone, lights up in the evening and sets the backyard aglow. The home merges old and new perfectly. Original, preserved hardwood floors with unique inset patterns adorn all rooms. Classic picture rail moldings allow you to hang art with ease. Modern touches feature a brand new central AC system; a stylish, renovated full bathroom; professionally painted interiors; and designer light fixtures in each room-in addition to the home's original stained glass chandelier. Practical improvements include a very rare heated driveway, custom cut wooden blinds, newer windows, gutter guards, French drains, sump pump, chimney liner and meticulously maintained systems. Set on a quiet tree-lined street one block away from the local farmer's market, gazebo with weekly music concerts, library, park - and steps from shops, and restaurants - this home uniquely balances beauty and function.
Floorplan
Property Information
9 Amherst Court, Maplewood NJ 07040
Listing Price: $789,000
3 Bedrooms
1 Full Bathroom | 1 Half Bathroom
1 Detached Garage
Lot Size: 0.12 acres
Property Style: Colonial
Ideal Closing: August 7, 2026
Estimated Taxes: $19,383* / 2025
*Inquire with tax assessor for 2026 numbers
FAVORITE FEATURES
A home rich with history and character, including artifacts discovered in the crawl space dating back to the 1800s and a foundation cornerstone marked 1927
Walkable to Maplecrest Park, where towering oak trees, a charming gazebo, playgrounds, and free summer concerts create a true neighborhood gathering place
Adjacent to the beloved Maplewood Farmers Market, making fresh produce, flowers, and local goods part of everyday life
Easy walk to the Maplewood Pool, perfect for sunny summer afternoons, community events, and making lifelong memories
Thoughtfully designed kitchen with a pass-through rear window, making outdoor dining and entertaining on the patio effortless
Built-in wine refrigerator and wine storage, ideal for hosting friends and family
Handcrafted stone patio and fire pit area, creating a favorite spot for outdoor dinners, neighborhood gatherings, and evenings filled with laughter
Beautiful butterfly bush along the driveway that bursts into bloom each August
Mature pink dogwood tree that welcomes spring with spectacular blossoms alongside seasonal tulips
Frequent visits from rabbits, songbirds, and other local wildlife that add to the property's garden charm
Rainbows often visible over the nearby Hilton Library, one of the many small moments that make this neighborhood feel magical
Walkable to the Maplewood Library, neighborhood shops, restaurants, Honey & Hive Artisan Ice Cream, and community events throughout the year
Easy access to Underhill Sports Complex and track for running, recreation, and community athletics
Close proximity to the South Mountain Reservation, offering miles of hiking trails, waterfalls, scenic overlooks, and year-round outdoor adventures
A neighborhood that embraces community through tennis tournaments, festivals, concerts, book clubs, volunteer opportunities, and meaningful friendships
Professionally maintained home with regular servicing of major systems, including boiler, air conditioning, termite prevention, and more
A unique antique radio antenna remains as a nod to the home's history and character
Convenient location offering the perfect balance of neighborhood tranquility and easy access to downtown Maplewood, transportation, parks, and recreation
UPDATES
2026
Full bathroom renovation completed
Interior of home professionally painted
USB-C charging ports added in kitchen
New kitchen chandelier installed
2025
New air conditioning compressor installed
New pillars and front porch refresh completed
New glass storm door installed
New colonial shutters with decorative tiebacks installed
2024
Custom-cut hardwood blinds installed throughout the home
Handcrafted stone patio with integrated lighting installed
Custom retaining wall constructed
Comprehensive French drain system installed
Updated light fixtures installed throughout the home
2022
Professionally landscaped front and backyard
Chimney liner replaced
Basement toilet ring and cement repaired/replaced
2021
State-of-the-art custom-designed kitchen renovation completed
French glass door installed in living room
Front porch pillars replaced and façade refreshed
2015
Sump pump installed
French drain system installed
2010
Heated driveway installed
Gutter guards installed
Ongoing Maintenance
Major systems professionally maintained and serviced on a regular schedule
APPROXIMATE MONTHLY UTILITIES
Electric::
$150
Gas:
$85
Water:
$55
Garbage:
$100/quarterly
Downloadable Documents
Map
Contact Information
VANESSA POLLOCK
Founder
Realtor® / Sales Associate
Direct: (973) 544-8484
Office: (973) 376-0033
Keller Williams Premier Properties
518 Millburn Avenue, Short Hills NJ